The questions and answers below will help you on your quest to snag some sweet Tico’s Whoopies!

What is a Whoopie Pie?

Tico’s Whoopies are the Picasso of all treats! Dense, moist, cake-like sandwiches surround a generous portion of luscious, creamy filling. It looks like a spaceship, tastes like heaven. Tico’s Whoopie Pies are a whoppingly huge masterpiece — nearly one-third of a pound! When you are looking for the most satisfaction, a four-inch Whoopie Pie is always better than a measly two-inch cupcake. Heck, it takes at least two or three piddly cupcakes to try and fill the shoes of just one Tico’s Whoopie Pie! Made from scratch the old fashioned way, no two are alike — each its own lovable hunk of edible art.

Whoopie Pies were born when leftover cake batter was baked into hamburger-shaped “Gobs,” then filled with sweet, fluffy creme. Upon opening lunch boxes, yells of “Whoopie!” were heard at first bite. Now, Tico’s brings homemade lovin’ to any of your special events, whether it’s a 96th birthday party, good luck on exams, The World’s Largest Gathering of Twins, a “Congrats, you did it!” celebration, or the occasional illicit affair!

If you are currently dieting, stop reading and click here because we only use the finest ingredients of European chocolate, fresh buttermilk, local eggs, creamy butter and fragrant vanilla. If you are worried about what you have to give up in order to get it this good, the answer is Marshmallow Fluff. UGH! Fluff is for sticks at camp fires and rice krispies treats — never, ever in a REAL homemade Tico’s Whoopie Pie!!

More addictive than social media, with Tico’s Whoopies your mouth never had it so good!


How do I care for my Whoopies?

Tico’s Whoopies need love, too–here’s how to keep them happy. We specialize in old-fashioned baked goods–made from scratch–using only the finest of ingredients. Because our Whoopies are expertly baked fresh daily, they are best enjoyed within a few days of receipt. For optimal taste and texture, please store your Whoopies out of direct sunlight in a cool, dry place–do not refrigerate. If you need to extend your Whoopie pleasure, you may freeze them for 90 days in an airtight container. Allow 1-2 hours to thaw at room temperature. If you can’t wait that long, they are pretty rad right out of the freezer as well!

Ingredient and Allergen Information?

Ingredients and allergen warnings will be included in every box of Whoopies. We specialize in old-fashioned baked goods, made from scratch. All of our Whoopie Pies are baked in a licensed, commercial kitchen and are individually wrapped. We only use the finest ingredients including European chocolate, fresh buttermilk, local eggs, and fragrant vanilla. Why? Because we believe that these ingredients truly make the best Whoopies, no mass production here!  And remember, our homemade ‘classic’ filling is the real deal, the way Whoopies have always been made in Pennsylvania- no marshmallow fluff in our kitchen!

ALLERGEN WARNING: We do not recommend consuming any of our products if you possess any of the following food allergies: wheat, egg, soy, dairy, peanuts, tree nuts, or gluten. Our Whoopie Pies contain: wheat, milk, soy, and egg and are made on equipment that also processes peanuts, tree nuts, wheat flour, soy, dairy, and eggs.

Will pricing information be included with my order?

No way, Jose! We do not include receipts or invoices inside our beautiful shipping boxes. (Come on, who wants to get a gift with the price tag on it? Except Minnie Pearl, perhaps.) Instead, you’ll receive a confirmation email with all that information in it.

Do you bake gluten-free, egg-free, dairy-free, sugar-free or vegan Whoopies?

We aren’t currently offering those options, but you never know what the future might hold!

Do you sell wholesale or do custom labels?

Yes, please contact us at (877)842-6588

When is a great time to Whoopie?

Want to be known as the best gift giver ever? Tico’s Whoopies will impress your recipients and at any of these special times:

  • Birthday
  • Wedding
  • Engagement
  • Anniversary – Home & Work
  • Showers- Baby & Bridal
  • Graduation
  • New Baby
  • New Home/Housewarming
  • New Job
  • Retirement
  • Bachelor/Bachelorette Party
  • Thank You
  • Corporate/Business
  • Honeymoon
  • Exams
  • Open House
  • Reunions
  • Charity Events
  • Holidays
  • Just Because
  • Just for ME!
  • Get Well
  • Sympathy
  • Love & Romance
  • Surprise
  • I’m Sorry
  • Good Luck
  • Religious
  • Bat Mitzvah
  • Bar Mitzvah
  • Teacher Appreciation
  • End of School Year
  • Grand Opening
  • New Business
  • Holiday Parties
  • Theme Parties
  • A Rave
  • Thinking of You

Did we miss a FABULOUS time to have a Tico’s Whoopie? Please share it with us!